News Command
News Command
Alaska Ballot Lists Two Men Named Dan Sullivan

Alaska Ballot Lists Two Men Named Dan Sullivan

By Avery Collins. Oct 28, 2026

Alaska’s U.S. Senate ballot includes two candidates named Dan Sullivan, and newly reported text messages have intensified a dispute over how one of them entered the race. The Republican incumbent, Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, is seeking reelection against Democrat Mary Peltola and two other candidates, including retired Petersburg schoolteacher Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.


The New York Times reported October 28 that people associated with Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee discussed recruiting candidates with the incumbent’s name. According to Associated Press reporting, the Times obtained text messages in which campaign associates discussed other people named Sullivan before the Petersburg candidate entered the race.


Messages, denials and a former campaign manager


The Times also interviewed former Peltola campaign manager Elisa Rios, who was fired during an August campaign shake-up. ‘Alaskan voters need to know,’ Rios told the newspaper, according to Alaska Public Media. She said voters deserved the full picture when making their decisions. The Times reported that she later tried to retract her statements.


The alleged recruitment formed part of what political operatives call a ‘ballot composition’ project: encouraging candidates to enter not necessarily to win, but to draw support from a stronger opponent. Alaska Public Media reported that super PACs had spent more than $2 million during the summer trying to elevate lesser-known candidates to the general-election ballot to disadvantage major contenders.


Peltola’s campaign denied involvement with either Sullivan campaign. The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee likewise denied participating in the second candidate’s bid. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. has previously rejected suggestions that his candidacy was arranged by Democrats and said he had no contact with Peltola’s campaign.


The two candidates are distinguishable on the ballot. Dan S. Sullivan is identified as the Republican incumbent; Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. is listed separately without a party affiliation. Alaska’s general-election ballot has four candidates, and voters rank their choices rather than selecting only one. The presence of a similarly named candidate could affect voter choices, but the eventual effect cannot be established before ballots are counted.


Courts have allowed the candidacy


State election officials initially sought to exclude the Petersburg candidate. Alaska’s Supreme Court ultimately permitted him to appear on the ballot. The recruitment allegations and the state court’s decision answer different questions: one concerns how the candidacy allegedly arose, while the other concerns access to the ballot under election law.


The U.S. Justice Department has also sued to prevent certification if incumbent Sullivan loses by fewer votes than the second Sullivan receives. The state Division of Elections, Peltola’s campaign and the League of Women Voters are among those disputing the legal basis for that intervention. A judge was expected to address dismissal motions as soon as Friday, according to Alaska Public Media.


Republicans argue the same-name strategy is different from ordinary efforts to promote a weaker opponent because it could confuse voters. Republican National Committee spokesman Nick Poche also raised a separate campaign-finance concern about potential coordination between a super PAC and Peltola’s campaign. That was the party’s allegation, not an announced finding of a campaign-finance violation.


Legal experts interviewed by AP and Alaska Public Media said the newly reported messages were unlikely to alter the federal case. Former Alaska state attorney Libby Bakalar argued that strategically recruiting candidates does not itself violate ballot-access law, while Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller called the alleged maneuver objectionable but said the decision was now in voters’ hands.


The controversy arrives after substantial early voting. State election officials said more than 60,000 Alaskans had already cast ballots by Wednesday, exceeding the total early vote in 2022, Alaska Public Media reported. Election Day is November 3. Both Sullivan names remain on the ballot as voters rank their choices and the federal case continues.


References: Democrat’s campaign reportedly helped recruit second Dan Sullivan for Alaska Senate race | Peltola campaign and national Dems recruited spoiler candidates, including Petersburg Sullivan, according to New York Times | Peltola campaign under fire after report that it recruited second Dan Sullivan for Alaska Senate race


AI Assisted Content

The News Command team was assisted by generative AI technology in creating this content

Trending